Chapter 3 

The Illusion of Choice 

When Your System Never Agreed

From 'Morning Waits'
7-8 minute read

This chapter challenges the myth of rational decision-making by revealing how beliefs get installed without your awareness or consent. Understanding this isn't disempowering, it's the beginning of actual agency.

A Freudian Slip

It was 2003, I was sitting at a bar in Stockholm Airport. CNN played silently with subtitles above the counter while Colin Powell addressed the United Nations. He was laying out the case for war in Iraq.

Next to me, a man turned and asked in a Swedish accent, 'Do you believe this?' 'No.' I answered. I surprised myself. Because up until that moment, I thought I did believe it. I had been saying so.

I had, like many others, given the benefit of the doubt to 'those who must know more than we do.' The security services. The leaders. The experts. My conscious narrative was that if they were acting, they must have reasons .. reasons we weren't allowed to know. But something inside me had already rejected the story.
Freud had a word for it … Parapraxis: a mistake in speech that reveals a deeper truth.

But it was more than that:

It was a flare, a signal from beneath the surface. I hadn't made a choice, I had discovered a choice that had already been made. We think that we choose our beliefs. But mostly, we don't.

Just Don't It

Let me give you a more relatable example: You decide to get fit. You mean it. You picture your future self as leaner, stronger, maybe standing tall under the spring morning sun. You buy a gym membership, and maybe some gear. Two weeks later, you're on the sofa, grazing on a full stomach, watching someone else do squats on YouTube.

What happened?

You weren't lying, you didn't change your mind, your conscious system still wants that result. But something else .. something deeper .. never signed up.

The chapter reveals the split between conscious intention and unconscious agreement:

When you made the decision to go to the gym, you engaged only the surface layer .. the verbal, narrative layer of mind. The part that constructs plans, tells stories, and makes statements like 'this time, it'll be different.' But that part isn't in charge of action. The unconscious is.

Stop Smoking

A revealing anecdote about unconscious motivation:

When cigarette packets in Europe first started to carry upsetting images of smoking-related diseases, I was standing next to a colleague who was buying a packet. The shopkeeper handed them over, and he handed them straight back. 'Can I have lung disease or heart disease or something? This one has erectile dysfunction. I don't want erectile dysfunction.'

He wasn't joking. To him, that was the stick he couldn't bear. He could overlook most consequences, but not that one. The image hit something primal, something evolutionarily precious. It struck below the reasoning mind.

The chapter explores how real change happens:

So if it's hard to get off the sofa and go to the gym through the carrot of inspiration alone, find your stick, let it all hang out in front of that mirror, and feel the motivation. Not a theoretical one, a felt one.

The Mirror and the Mechanism

There is a strange moment that can happen if you catch yourself in the act of thinking. You're going about your day, and suddenly a thought appears. Not one you constructed. Not one you asked for. It's just there .. fully formed, fully voiced.

You notice it, and then you realise: I didn't decide to think that. It just arrived. This is the moment when you realise that not only are you not writing the script .. most of the time, you're not even aware that a script is running.

The chapter reveals how beliefs actually get installed:

Most of your thoughts .. especially the fast, reactive ones .. are echoes of others. And most of your beliefs were never chosen. They were installed. And as we saw earlier, beliefs are installed by repetition, emotion, and trust, often in moments you didn't even realise were formative.

The process is unconscious and automatic:

The human mind isn't truth-seeking. It's a coherence-seeking system. We're not wired to want to be right. We're wired to want to feel right. And feeling right means matching the people around us.

The Installation Process

If you grow up in a home where one political party is praised and the other demonised, your unconscious takes notes. If the adults you trust treat certain institutions with reverence, you inherit their reverence.

At some point … often in high school, college, or university … your environment shifts. The people you admire, want to impress, or simply want to feel safe around, change. And so do the flags: political affiliations, social ideals, institutional loyalties.

For many parents, it feels like a loss. For many students, it feels like waking up. It's that same system … tribal, emotional, survival-focused … recalibrating to secure belonging in a new social centre of gravity.

The mechanism is always the same:

Let's say you walk into a room full of people you admire, and they're all talking about how dangerous a certain idea is. Even if you don't know much about it .. even if you've never heard of it before .. you'll likely come away with a sense of unease around that idea.

The System Is Sane

If you've made it this far, you've probably already started to feel it: that subtle vertigo that comes from seeing your own mind from the outside. You're not alone. In fact, the moment you can say, 'Wait .. how much of me is actually me?' is the moment you've already begun waking up.

But first, an important clarification:

There is nothing wrong with you. Nothing is broken or defective. You are not mentally ill, you are a perfectly adapted human running on code that was never written for this world. You are sane.

What's insane is the mismatch between the machinery inside you and the society around you. Your brain evolved to survive in Palaeolithic tribal groups of between 100 and 150 people.

You were never meant to process thousands of conflicting headlines a day. Or keep up with a global conversation. Or compare yourself to curated avatars of strangers from every corner of the planet.

The unease you feel? It's not dysfunction. It's your system screaming the truth: 'This doesn't make sense. This doesn't feel safe. This isn't right.'

The Real Diagnosis

We are living in a society that treats the symptoms of cognitive misalignment as if they are personal defects. Depressed? Take a pill. Anxious? Take a breath. Confused, overwhelmed, or disillusioned? Log off. Tune out. Carry on.

But the truth is different:

Most modern suffering is not the result of mental illness, it's the result of mental misalignment. The tools we've been given to understand ourselves are out of date. The models are incomplete. The language is wrong.

The Beginning of Agency

When we believe that our perceptions directly reflect reality, we become absolutists, convinced that those who see things differently must be either stupid or evil. When we believe that our judgments derive from careful analysis, we become immune to evidence that might improve the accuracy of our views.

Understanding the system changes everything:

And that is the first real freedom. Not the ability to choose everything, but the awareness of what was never chosen. Not the power to control the mind, but the humility to observe it.

This is the moment where the self stops being a tyrant and becomes a partner. Where the illusion of choice gives way to something deeper: Conscious participation in a system you no longer need to suppress and control, because once you understand it, the system starts to respond.

What This Chapter Reveals

Chapter 3 shows that the "choices" you think you're making are often responses generated by inherited programming. But recognising this isn't disempowering, it's the beginning of actual agency.

Once you see that most beliefs were installed rather than chosen, you can begin to examine them consciously. This doesn't mean rejecting everything you believe, but understanding where your beliefs came from and whether they're still serving you.

The chapter reveals that freedom isn't about having unlimited choice, but about conscious participation in the systems that shape your reality. Once you understand how the installation process works, you can begin to update your programming deliberately rather than being unconsciously programmed by your environment.

This understanding is crucial for Chapter 4's exploration of how our perceptual reality itself is constructed, and how recognising this opens the door to conscious participation in reality creation.

Copyright © 2025 David Tomlinson
Morning Waits | Wellisford Press | Wellisford Consulting. All rights reserved.

Amazon's trademark is used under license from Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.

Copyright © 2025 David Tomlinson
Morning Waits | Wellisford Press | Wellisford Consulting. All rights reserved.

Amazon's trademark is used under license from Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.

Copyright © 2025 David Tomlinson
Morning Waits | Wellisford Press | Wellisford Consulting. All rights reserved.

Amazon's trademark is used under license from Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.